AI Tutors: Do we still need teachers? — from donaldclarkplanb.blogspot.com by Donald Clark

AI is increasingly capable of explaining, questioning, diagnosing, providing feedback and adapting practice. These are central components of tutoring, and it can already perform many of them effectively. What humans often contribute is something different: motivation, supervision, social interaction, safeguarding, judgement and organisation.

For younger children, that human presence appears valuable. But the Indian evidence suggests it need not always come from a qualified subject teacher. For older learners, university students and adults, the need for supervision may be substantially lower.

This doesn’t mean teachers disappear. It means we should stop assuming that every educational task requires a teacher.

Nor should we assume that putting ChatGPT in front of pupils automatically improves learning. The most convincing results come from carefully designed tutoring experiences, with appropriate scaffolding, feedback and opportunities for practice.

There is, however, a more fundamental point. We have spent centuries organising education around the scarcity of teachers and tutors. AI is removing that scarcity. Classrooms, timetables, age-based cohorts, lectures and fixed courses are, in part, ways of distributing limited human expertise among large numbers of learners. When personalised, one-to-one tutoring becomes abundant and extraordinarily cheap, those assumptions become open to question.

 

AI Raises Big Questions for the Future of Teacher Education — from edweek.org by Alyson Klein

When Shannon Kane recounts giving a low grade to an aspiring teacher for turning in a lesson plan crafted by artificial intelligence, the other students in the professor’s class naturally assume the problem was cheating.

But to Kane, the biggest issue wasn’t that this student used AI.

It was that she used it poorly.
.


.

“The tools are already there for everyone to use, with or without the critical dispositions and understandings to use them well,” Kane said. “We can’t decide for [teacher] candidates whether they’ll use the tools. But we can make sure that if candidates opt to use the tools, they are prepared to judge what the tools give them.”

Compounding the problem: Teacher preparation has long struggled—and in some cases, neglected—figuring out how to effectively prepare aspiring teachers to integrate technology into instruction. More than half of new teachers—56 percent—lack confidence in using technology when they enter the classroom for the first time, according to a 2023 report by the International Society for Transforming Education (ISTE).

 

Is College Getting Too Easy? — from linkedin.com by Jeff Selingo

“Learning requires struggle. Learning requires effort,” a provost said at one of my dinners in Seattle. He argued that faculty may need to make courses and assignments harder, not easier.

Think about the contradiction. For 20 years, the student success movement has focused on removing barriers. Now AI may require colleges to preserve some of them. If AI does the easy work, where do students get the practice to handle harder problems? How much must they know before it’s safe to hand a task to a machine?

RPI is piloting AI tutors in five courses across its five schools this semester. They’re limited to course materials and designed to ask Socratic questions rather than simply supply answers. Schmidt hopes they can help students master introductory material more efficiently, leaving time for harder, hands-on learning.

 

With thanks to Paul Fain for this resource,
and who also mentioned the First Rung Observatory.

 
 

3 Habits Students Can Develop to Find Credible Online Resources — from edutopia.org by Michael Yell
As students become more acquainted with social media and AI, these habits can help them distinguish credible sources from misinformation.

1. Teaching Students to Ask, ‘Who’s Behind the Information?’
2. Teaching Students to Read Laterally on the Web, Not Vertically
3. Teaching Habits of Mind, Not Checklists
.


Also related/see:

Check out several resources from my sister, Sue Ellen Christian, a Professor of Communication at Western Michigan University:

  • Wonder Media: Ask the Questions
    This website is dedicated to helping you learn more about how to use the media for your purposes, and not to be used by media. The contents of the site are divided to facilitate selection of activities. For games, videos, quizzes, music and more focused on general media use, select from the Media Literacy Toolkit. For activities focused on information and news use, see the News Literacy Toolkit.
    .

 

 
 

EdTech’s Cybersecurity Reckoning — from onedtech.philhillaa.com by Phil Hill
The Canvas breach was an early marker of a new reality. PHP2Shell shows why EdTech’s move toward managed services will accelerate.

Higher education has a particularly large exposure because so much of its technology grew through local initiative: someone built a useful tool, installed an open-source application, or kept a departmental website running. That approach delivered considerable value and fit the education ethos, but it also distributed responsibility for maintaining and defending software across multiple teams and individuals with very different capabilities.

I believe we are entering a period that will significantly accelerate the move toward managed services, shared infrastructure, and restrictions on locally operated applications exposed to the public internet, particularly for under-resourced institutions. This reaches into budgets, institutional autonomy, and the ways educational technology gets built and delivered—well beyond the immediate work of a CIO responding to a security alert.

 

Are We Sending Young People False Signals About Their Futures? — from workshift.org by Emily M. Dickens and Elissa Salas

For years, we’ve told young people that training + credentials = opportunity. And for many pathways, that’s still true. But an AI-disrupted labor market is forcing us to be uncomfortably honest about what has always been a much more complicated equation.

Mixed Signals
Today’s young people need us to be able to say that we don’t fully know what the future of work looks like. Mixed signals abound. For example, at major tech companies, new graduate and entry-level hiring is down roughly 65% compared to 2019 pre-pandemic levels. So far in 2026, AI has been cited in more than 120K announced job cuts.

On the other hand, major companies including Google and CSX announced plans to hire to meet growth goals. Some of the fastest-growing occupations range across healthcare, skilled trades, and tech. In September, Business Roundtable’s CEO Economic Outlook Index showed a seven-point increase in hiring plans. The messages sent to young people are genuinely contradictory, and we need to help them cut through the noise.

Helping young people develop in this way will require smarter, stronger bridges between the systems that shape our workforce, such as better connecting K-12 classrooms to career pathways, aligning higher education institutions with the evolving job market, and ensuring untapped talent has access to in-demand employment opportunities. 

 

Experts say higher education is an industry in turmoil. The collateral damage is widespread — from hechingerreport.org by Jon Marcus
Colleges are closing at a pace equivalent to about one every three weeks, with more projected

AMHERST, Mass. — The parking lots are mostly vacant. Locked and dark, many of the buildings are lifeless but for dying plants in dusty pots. One of the few people visible is a white-bearded man on a riding mower, tending to an empty lawn as if by habit.

This is not a factory or office park abandoned by its tenants. It’s Hampshire College, a once-celebrated liberal arts school that will shut down in December. That makes it the latest in a steady stream of colleges that are closing or merging, at a rate that last year reached the equivalent of nearly one every three weeks.

“Everyone is shocked to hear that more than a quarter of our private colleges could be gone in the next decade,” said Peter Stokes, a managing director at Huron Consulting Group, which has projected that 442 of the nation’s 1,700 still-operating private, nonprofit universities and colleges are at risk of having to close or merge in the next 10 years. “We’re now talking about hundreds of other institutions being in a similar situation.”


Also see:


The State of Higher Ed 2026, in 4 Charts — from linked.com by Jeff Selingo

For nearly 60 years, higher ed had one answer to almost every strategic question: get bigger. Add programs, schools, enrollment, research labs, campuses, athletic teams, international students, online degrees.

That era is ending.

That’s the central argument running through this year’s State of Higher Education, my annual briefing for presidents, trustees, cabinets, and faculty leaders. Like last year’s inaugural deck, it borrows from Mary Meeker’s “Internet Trends”: heavy on charts, quick to scan, built for leadership teams to work through together.

The 2026 edition covers six areas: the business model, federal policy, research, AI, athletics, and governance. The question across all of them is what’s temporary and what’s structural. Each section ends with a page of opportunities for leaders.

Here are four charts from the briefing and what they tell us about what’s next…

 

Develop students’ oracy with these activities — from timeshighereducation.com. by Paul Demetriou
Oracy skills can empower graduates to contribute meaningfully to societal challenges in an increasingly dynamic and interconnected world, says Paul Demetriou, who shares practical advice

University students should be able to speak well about their subject, but they don’t automatically learn to question, reason and defend ideas simply by studying it. Many students have underdeveloped critical thinking skills when they enter higher education, because primary and secondary education often emphasises rote memorisation over analytical thinking. In addition, students transitioning to university might find it challenging to adapt to independent and self-directed learning, which demands deeper reasoning and justification of ideas.

The ability to question, reason and defend is crucial in today’s world, in which graduates must navigate misinformation, solve complex problems and make informed decisions. These skills can empower graduates to engage in debates and innovate in professional settings and contribute meaningfully to societal challenges in an increasingly dynamic and interconnected world. Here are strategies to develop these skills in the classroom.

 

The Faculty Bargain Of 2040: What Should The University And Its Faculty Owe One Another? — from forbes.com by David Rosowsky

What if we stopped reforming the existing faculty career for a moment? What if we started over?

Suppose we were designing the faculty career today for the university of 2040, starting with a blank sheet of paper. There would be no rigid departmental affiliations, ranks, tenure systems, promotion policies, or inherited assumptions. We could keep anything that still made sense. But nothing would be presumed necessary simply because it has been around for decades.

What would we build?

When machines can increasingly perform parts of the work that once consumed enormous amounts of human time, the scarce attributes may shift toward judgment, curiosity, creativity, disciplinary depth, the ability to frame consequential questions, the capacity to connect ideas across fields, and the ability to know when a machine is wrong.

That is not an argument for fewer faculty. It may be an argument for different faculty – and for a faculty employment system capable of recognizing those important (even desirable) differences.

 

 

Light Bulb Moments from 100 Episodes — from intentionalteaching.buzzsprout.com by Derek Bruff

Per Derek:

Welcome to the 100th episode of Intentional Teaching! I am very excited to reach this milestone, and I am deeply grateful to all my guests and all my listeners for making this possible. I learn so much from my guests, and I’m thrilled to know that folks out there appreciate the interviews and the show.

In this 100th episode, I take a look back at some of the light bulb moments I’ve had interviewing guests over the last four years. What quotes and ideas and examples have really stuck with me and informed my work? 

My hope is that you’ll find these moments interesting and perhaps useful to your work in higher education, and that this clip show might interest you in digging into the podcast archives and listening to some older episodes.

 

Online Course Video Statistics — from markstudios.com by Mark Santos

“Every figure on this page links to the organization that produced it, and each was re-checked against that source before publishing. How many people take online courses, how big the platforms are, how long course videos actually hold attention, how many learners finish, what the money looks like, and which popular online course statistics do not survive being traced to their origin.”
.

 

Want to Close the Skills Gap? Bring Learning Closer to Work — from campustechnology.com by Elise Awwad

Key Takeaways

  • The skills gap is a workforce access problem as much as a talent problem: Employers broadly plan to upskill workers, yet many employees still lack sufficient time or access to AI training.
  • AI fluency compounds where workers already have access: Employees who use AI regularly build confidence and capability, while those whose jobs keep them farther from the technology risk falling further behind.
  • Upskilling works better when learning is integrated with work: Employers and higher education should create pathways that combine technical and durable skills with on-the-job application, rather than treating reskilling as an individual responsibility.

The skills employers say they cannot find are increasingly the skills they expect employees and candidates to arrive with, fully formed, at their own expense.
…
Upskilling or reskilling is often framed as an individual responsibility: a matter of initiative, of staying current. But if employers need these skills, they have a stake in making sure workers have a realistic way to develop them.

 
© 2025 | Daniel Christian