Imagining Successful Schools — from nytimes.com by Joe Nocera
Excerpt:
The main thing that works is treating teaching as a profession, and teachers as professionals. That means that teachers are as well paid as other professionals, that they have a career ladder, that they go to elite schools where they learn their craft, and that they are among the top quartile of college graduates instead of the bottom quartile. When I suggested that American cities couldn’t afford to pay teachers the way we pay engineers or lawyers, Tucker scoffed. With rare exception, he said, the cost per pupil in the places with the best educational systems is less than the American system, even though their teachers are far better paid. “They are not spending more money; they are spending money differently,” he said.
…
Tucker envisions the same kind of accountability for teachers as exists for, say, lawyers in a firm — where it is peers holding each other accountable rather than some outside force. People who don’t pull their own weight are asked to leave. The ethos is that people help each other to become better for the good of the firm.
From DSC:
With a special thanks going out to James Bratt,
Professor of History at Calvin College, for this resource.
The first paragraph is great. The second paragraph, not so great. The profession of being a lawyer is a terrible model to use as something that runs well. Especially since the first paragraph is comparing teaching in the US to other countries, the author should also take into account being a lawyer on a larger scale. Being a lawyer outside of the US is very different than being a lawyer in the US. Most countries in the world expect their citizens to at least half-way protect themselves from seemingly unsafe situations (like spilling hot coffee on your self). In the US a lawyer’s job it to make more work for other lawyers.
Thanks Kyle for the comment here. I mainly posted it as a small attempt to address the misplaced priorities we have here in the U.S. As my daughter commented the other day, “Why do we pay millions to athletes to put a ball through a hoop or hit one out of the park but we don’t pay and support people like teachers who are on the front lines making a real difference in peoples’ lives?!”
Again, thanks for taking the time to drop me this comment Kyle.
Peace,
Daniel