AI Tutors: Do we still need teachers? — from donaldclarkplanb.blogspot.com by Donald Clark
AI is increasingly capable of explaining, questioning, diagnosing, providing feedback and adapting practice. These are central components of tutoring, and it can already perform many of them effectively. What humans often contribute is something different: motivation, supervision, social interaction, safeguarding, judgement and organisation.
For younger children, that human presence appears valuable. But the Indian evidence suggests it need not always come from a qualified subject teacher. For older learners, university students and adults, the need for supervision may be substantially lower.
This doesn’t mean teachers disappear. It means we should stop assuming that every educational task requires a teacher.
Nor should we assume that putting ChatGPT in front of pupils automatically improves learning. The most convincing results come from carefully designed tutoring experiences, with appropriate scaffolding, feedback and opportunities for practice.
There is, however, a more fundamental point. We have spent centuries organising education around the scarcity of teachers and tutors. AI is removing that scarcity. Classrooms, timetables, age-based cohorts, lectures and fixed courses are, in part, ways of distributing limited human expertise among large numbers of learners. When personalised, one-to-one tutoring becomes abundant and extraordinarily cheap, those assumptions become open to question.




